ExtremismLedger is a living public-interest database. Records are continuously reviewed, updated, and expanded as new verified information becomes available.

Missouri Legislators Threaten Supreme Court Impeachment Over Hoskins Contempt Proceeding

Documented · 09/09/2026

On September 9, 2026, fourteen Missouri legislators (nine state senators and five state representatives) signed a two-page letter on Missouri General Assembly letterhead to Chief Justice W. Brent Powell of the Supreme Court of Missouri concerning the pending case von Glahn v. Hoskins (No. SC101805). The court had ordered Secretary of State Denny Hoskins to appear on September 10 at 10:00 a.m. to show cause why he should not be held in contempt of its September 3 injunction, and had stated that it would not accept filings from other parties or amici.

The letter, reported as delivered late on September 9, argued that holding Hoskins in contempt for following a federal temporary restraining order would violate the Supremacy Clause, and stated: "Should Secretary Hoskins be held in contempt, we will petition the Speaker of the House and legislative leadership to begin impeachment proceedings against the responsible members of this Court for willful neglect of duty, incompetency, and misconduct under Article VII, Sections 1 and 2 of the Missouri Constitution." It asked that the show-cause proceeding "not be converted into an order requiring defiance of the federal TRO."

On September 10 the court found that Hoskins had been in contempt, found that he had purged the contempt, and imposed no fine or commitment. No articles of impeachment against any judge have been identified as filed in sources reviewed through October 8, 2026, and no court, disciplinary body, or legislative body has made a finding about the letter.

Documented claims

Documented fact 10/08/2026

As of October 8, 2026, no articles of impeachment against any member of the Supreme Court of Missouri had been identified as filed in the sources reviewed; House Speaker Jon Patterson was reported as saying, "That's not where my head is at this point."

Editorial classification 10/08/2026

Editorial classification: ExtremismLedger documents the September 9, 2026 letter under Editorial Policy §0 criterion 8 (attempted subversion of the norm of independent courts). The signers, identifying themselves by legislative office, told the Chief Justice they would seek the impeachment of the responsible judges if the court reached a specific outcome in a pending case, the evening before the hearing and after the court had barred non-party filings; a threatened removal proceeding expressly conditioned on a pending ruling is reasonably capable of pressuring judicial decision-making. This is an editorial classification, not a legal finding: no court or other authority has found the letter coercive or unlawful, no impeachment articles have been identified as filed, and the signers stated that their purpose was to uphold the Supremacy Clause and the separation of powers.

Documented fact 09/09/2026

On September 9, 2026, fourteen Missouri legislators signed a letter warning that they would petition legislative leadership to begin impeachment proceedings against responsible Missouri Supreme Court members if Denny Hoskins were held in contempt.

Documented fact 09/09/2026

The September 9, 2026 letter, signed by fourteen Missouri legislators and addressed to Chief Justice W. Brent Powell, stated: "Should Secretary Hoskins be held in contempt, we will petition the Speaker of the House and legislative leadership to begin impeachment proceedings against the responsible members of this Court for willful neglect of duty, incompetency, and misconduct under Article VII, Sections 1 and 2 of the Missouri Constitution."

Documented fact 09/08/2026

The Supreme Court of Missouri's September 8, 2026 order to show cause set argument for September 10, 2026 at 10:00 a.m., ordered Secretary of State Denny Hoskins to appear in person, and stated that the court would not allow filings from any other parties or amici on the matter.

Relationships

Confirmed Associated with — Adam Schnelting (Letter signer)

09/09/2026

Confirmed Associated with — Ben Brown (Letter signer)

09/09/2026

Confirmed Associated with — Bob Titus (Letter signer)

09/09/2026

Confirmed Associated with — Brad Hudson (Letter signer)

09/09/2026

Confirmed Associated with — Chad Perkins (Letter signer)

09/09/2026

Confirmed Associated with — Curtis Trent (Letter signer)

09/09/2026

Confirmed Associated with — Hardy Billington (Letter signer)

09/09/2026

Confirmed Associated with — Jamie Burger (Letter signer)

09/09/2026

Confirmed Associated with — Jason Bean (Letter signer)

09/09/2026

Confirmed Associated with — Jeff Myers (Letter signer)

09/09/2026

Confirmed Associated with — Jill Carter (Letter signer)

09/09/2026

Confirmed Associated with — Joe Nicola (Letter signer)

09/09/2026

Confirmed Associated with — Mike McGirl (Letter signer)

09/09/2026

Confirmed Associated with — Rick Brattin (Letter signer)

09/09/2026